If you are a member of Costco, they are almost always the cheapest for us.
3:28pm on 7/26/26 by
matterhorn55
Yes, checked Costco first but same rate as our local Enterprise. I've on my 4th rental this week because of problems with rentals!
3:33pm on 7/26/26 by
snowdiz
Not to pry but curious. What kind of trouble?
3:33pm on 7/26/26 by
MOJoe
not widely available but if you are in a market with Flexcar, its useful for longer term rentals.
https://www.flexcar.com/
3:34pm on 7/26/26 by
thrasher543
I used Turo when I bought a new car to try out lots of different options. Not sure how that works if you're doing insurance reimbursement though.
3:38pm on 7/26/26 by
mary32830
Some Subaru dealerships do rentals of their service loaners to anyone.
4:05pm on 7/26/26 by
touringmom
That's nice when my car was totaled my insurance company gave me 5 days. I got a cheap high mileage car mine came form Subaru but im not brand picky. I did want a 4 wheel drive
4:09pm on 7/26/26 by
WorldTraveler34
U.K. may be different but we had a rental thru insurance when ds18 car was written iff(not his fault!). It only gave me 10 days free after accepting insurance settlement but I was able to keep paying for it until new lease car arrived. Harder as only 18
4:21pm on 7/26/26 by
hodg
My insurance gave 72 hours of rental car after declaring the car totaled. (Progressive). @MOJoe, one car was too small, one got nail in tire and tire had to be ordered, yesterday "Check Engine" light came on, now given Hyundai Kona until tomorrow.
4:42pm on 7/26/26 by
snowdiz
Our local Toyota dealerships offer long term loans with unlimited miles. We are in south central PA
8:36pm on 7/26/26 by
momshappyplace
I have a slightly used/damaged scooter you can borrow.
9:45pm on 7/26/26 by
trishr.
@snow my insurance was 30 days @35/d but after I accepted settlement (day7) I had another 7 days at their expense. Liberty Mutual and Enterprise let me keep rental at same rate but billed to me instead of LM. Does yours have that option? ...
10:17pm on 7/26/26 by
Magicalday2011
...
https://carrentalsavers.com/. This was posted here a few months ago. Maybe check it out for your area. I'm sorry for your stress. I get it! Sunroof open in rainstorm overnight also totals your car. Maybe steer away from sunroofs
10:19pm on 7/26/26 by
Magicalday2011
Was the deer ok?
7:35am by
Fatty McButterpants
Pretty sure she said no.
8:53am by
hodg
@ Trish hahaha!!
Sorry for the stress @snowdiz. But thankful you are ok.
9:20am by
jenc45
@snowdiz, some rental companies (hertz and enterprise) , will allow you to stay in same rental at the insurance company (lower) negotiated rate if you need to as long as agree to pay. Sometimes they will do it if you ask / explain, or sometimes ins co
9:41am by
RememberTheMagic
will need to call and advise you need the rental longer. The ins co I worked for , we would do it ALL the time for our insureds.
The rental companies are ones we have contracts with and usually not a problem at all for them.
9:44am by
RememberTheMagic
Update: I have been told I can keep my current rental car at the same rate Progressive was paying. I've booked it for the week so far, but it's doubtful I will have a new vehicle before then. I am a FL resident with car titled there but accident in WI.
1:57pm by
snowdiz